November 19, 2026
/
Will Rent Cover Your Mortgage? Do the Real Math First

Will Rent Cover Your Mortgage? Do the Real Math First

Tired of managing your rentals or having other companies fall short?
Evernest is here to help.
Looking to buy or sell rental property?
Evernest makes it easy.

Will Rent Cover Your Mortgage? Do the Real Math First

By Matthew Whitaker, founder of Evernest.

Quick disclaimer: I am not your CPA or your attorney. The numbers below are examples, and your own taxes, insurance, and costs will differ. Talk to your own tax professional before you act on any of this.

If you're thinking about renting your house and your whole plan is that the rent will cover the mortgage, this post is for you. Grab a pen. We'll do the real math line by line and end with one monthly number you can trust. I'm Matthew Whitaker, founder of Evernest. We have local teams who manage homes across the US, and I wrote the book How to Rent Your Home.

The short version

The short version: Most owners do this math in one line: rent minus mortgage. That one line leaves out the costs that hit all at once. Use a two-column sheet instead: money out on the left (mortgage, taxes, insurance, HOA, repair reserve, help, the turn, and the repair you've been putting off) and money in on the right (real rent, minus vacancy, plus pet rent). Then read your number: rent it, fix the gap, or sell. Covering the mortgage isn't the same as covering the house.

Why one-line math fails

Draw a line down the middle of a page: money out on the left, money in on the right. Most owners I talk to do this math in one line, rent minus mortgage. If it's positive, they feel good.

That one line leaves out a lot of what it costs to own a rental, and the costs it misses are the ones that hit all at once. In the book, I say the number one mistake is optimism on rent and amnesia on costs. This sheet fixes both.

The left side: money out

Line one: your mortgage. Principal and interest only. If taxes and insurance are in your payment, split them out.

Line two: property taxes. Take the yearly bill and divide it by 12. Taxes can go up after a new assessment, and some places give a tax break on the home you live in. Call your county and ask: does my bill change if this becomes a rental?

Line three: insurance. Your homeowner's policy is built for a house you live in. A rental needs a landlord policy, and it often costs more, so don't write down your old number. Get a real quote and expect it to rise. In the book, I warn that a premium can jump 30% at one renewal.

Line four: HOA dues, plus any special assessments you know are coming.

Line five: the repair reserve. This is money you set aside monthly so a broken AC isn't an emergency. In the book, I tell owners to plan on 1% of the home's value per year. Divide that by 12. If the house is older or has a pool or a septic system, plan on more.

Line six: help, if you'll hire it. A manager usually charges 8% to 10% of the rent they collect, and often a leasing fee too. If you only hire out the leasing, write down that cost instead. If you'll do it all yourself, write zero.

Line seven: the turn. Between residents, the power, water, and lawn are on you, plus cleaning and paint. It's not every month, but it's coming, so your reserve has to cover it.

Line eight: the repair you've been putting off. This one goes at the bottom by itself. The water heater that rumbles, the roof with a few years left in it. You know the one. It's a one-time cost, not monthly, but a resident will find it fast. Fix it on your schedule, not theirs.

The right side: money in

The right side is shorter, and it's where people fool themselves.

Line one: real rent. What homes like yours actually rented for lately. Not what you need or hope for. Get it from more than one source and use the number where they agree.

Line two: subtract vacancy. Even good rentals sit empty sometimes. In the book, the safe plan is one month of rent per year, which is about 8%.

Line three: pet rent, if you allow pets. Most owners charge $25 to $50 a month per pet. One rule here: service animals and emotional support animals are not pets. No pet rent on those, ever.

Example one: a house where the math works

Let's run one together, with rounded numbers. Say your house is worth $240,000, and homes like it have been renting for $1,800 a month.

Money out:

  • Principal and interest: $1,000
  • Taxes: $200
  • Landlord insurance: $125
  • HOA: none
  • Repair reserve: 1% of $240,000 is $2,400 a year, or $200 a month
  • Help: zero, because you'll manage it yourself

Total out: $1,525.

Money in: $1,800 minus one month a year of vacancy, which is $150 a month, so $1,650.

$1,650 in, $1,525 out. You're up $125 a month.

Now look at what the one-line math said: $1,800 in rent minus a $1,325 payment (principal, interest, taxes, and insurance) is $475 a month, easy money. The real number is $125. That's still a yes. It's just a much thinner yes. Covering the mortgage isn't the same as covering the house.

Example two: a house where it doesn't work

I see this one a lot. Say you bought more recently, so the payment is bigger. The house is worth $330,000, and comps say $2,400 a month.

Money out:

  • Principal and interest: $1,650
  • Taxes: $250
  • Insurance: $150
  • HOA: $50
  • Repair reserve: 1% of $330,000 is about $275 a month
  • Manager: you're moving away, so you'll hire one at 10% of rent collected, which is $220

Total out: $2,595.

Money in: $2,400 minus $200 for vacancy, which is $2,200.

The one-line math says you're up $300, and that feels great. The full sheet says you're short about $395 a month. The rent covers the mortgage. It doesn't cover the house.

Is a $395 monthly gap a bad deal?

Not automatically. Here's the honest answer, both ways.

The case for it. A rental pays you in more ways than rent. Every payment also pays down your loan. Say that loan is about $260,000 at 6.5%. Early on, about $235 of each payment goes to principal. That's money moving into your equity. So you're short $395 in cash, but about $235 comes back to you in equity, and your real cost is closer to $160 a month. And over 10 or 20 years, homes in most markets have gone up in value. Not every year, but over time. For some owners, $160 a month to own a growing asset is a great trade. (We break down the four ways a rental makes you money in a separate post.)

The case against it. A small negative is a real problem when you can't carry it. If it comes out of your grocery money, or one big repair would go on a credit card, that's a problem. In the book, the cushion is six months of the full house payment plus $5,000 for repairs.

Here's my test: a negative you plan for is an investment. A negative that surprises you is a problem.

One more line for your sheet: taxes

Rental income is taxable, but you also get deductions and something called depreciation. Those can change your real rent number, sometimes a lot. That's a CPA conversation. Bring them the sheet.

Three decisions your number points to

Decision one: rent it. Your number is positive, or it's a planned small negative and you have the cushion.

Decision two: fix the gap. Here's what actually moves the number:

  • Condition moves rent. Neutral paint, clean floors, and a deep clean push you toward the top of your comps.
  • Allowing pets adds pet rent and more applicants.
  • Shop your landlord insurance.
  • Check your tax assessment, and appeal it if it's wrong.
  • Keep a good resident. Every turnover you avoid saves you real money.
  • Resize your help. You can hire out just the leasing or just the repairs.

Those moves can close a small gap. They rarely close a big one.

Decision three: sell. If the gap is big, you don't have the cushion, or you have a put-off repair like a roof, sell. I run a property management company and I'll still tell you that. Selling is a smart answer, not a failure.

"My rent covers the mortgage, so I'm fine"

Maybe you are. Let's test it. Say your rent beats your full payment by $300 a month. That's $3,600 a year. Now your resident moves out after year one. In the book, I say turnover usually costs one to two months of rent all in. On a $2,400 rent, that's $2,400 to $4,800. That's your whole year of profit, maybe more. And that's before the AC dies in July.

Rent covering the mortgage tells you about one month. The sheet tells you about the whole year. Run the whole sheet. If it still works, great. Now you know it instead of hoping for it.

Quick recap

  • Money out: mortgage, taxes, insurance, HOA, repair reserve, your help, the turn, and the repair you've been putting off.
  • Money in: real rent, minus vacancy, plus pet rent where it fits.
  • Read your number. Positive or planned: rent it. A gap you can close: fix it. A big gap or no cushion: sell it and feel good about it.

It's your house. Just make the call with the whole sheet, not one line.

Frequently asked questions

Will rent cover my mortgage if I rent out my house?Maybe, but rent covering the mortgage isn't the same as covering the house. Taxes, landlord insurance, HOA, a repair reserve, vacancy, and management all come out too. In our first example, a $475 one-line gap shrank to $125 a month once the full sheet was done, and in our second it turned into a $395 shortfall.

How much should I budget for repairs on a rental?In the book, I tell owners to plan on 1% of the home's value per year, divided by 12 for a monthly number. On a $240,000 house, that's $200 a month. If the house is older or has a pool or a septic system, plan on more.

How much vacancy should I plan for?The safe plan is one month of rent per year, which is about 8%. Even good rentals sit empty sometimes. On $1,800 rent, that's $150 a month. The power, water, lawn, cleaning, and paint between residents are on you, so your reserve has to cover them too.

How much does property management cost?A manager usually charges 8% to 10% of the rent they collect, and often a leasing fee too. If you only hire out the leasing, count that cost instead. If you'll do it all yourself, write zero. In our second example, 10% of rent collected was $220 a month.

Does landlord insurance cost more than homeowner's insurance?Often, yes. A homeowner's policy is built for a house you live in, and a rental needs a landlord policy. Get a real quote instead of using your old number, and expect it to rise. In the book, I warn that a premium can jump 30% at one renewal.

Can I charge pet rent for a service animal?No. Service animals and emotional support animals are not pets, so there's no pet rent on those, ever. For pets, most owners charge $25 to $50 a month per pet.

Is it okay to rent a house at a small monthly loss?It can be, if you plan for it and can carry it. Part of each payment goes to principal, which builds your equity, and homes in most markets have gone up in value over the long run. But you need a cushion: six months of the full house payment plus $5,000 for repairs. A planned negative is an investment. A surprise is a problem.

Where to go from here

If you want a real rent number for the line on the right side of your sheet, start with a free rental analysis. If you're still deciding whether to rent your house at all, my book, How to Rent Your Home, walks you through the whole decision, including this math. It also comes with a set of landlord checklists, including a rent ready checklist.

Get a free rental analysis on your property

Download the free book, How to Rent Your Home

No pressure, no obligation.

‍

Matthew Whitaker
Matthew Whitaker is the founder of Evernest, which manages thousands of houses across 50 U.S. cities, and the author of How to Rent Your Home.