721 Exchange (UPREIT): How It Works for Rental Owners

By Matthew Whitaker, founder of Evernest.

Quick disclaimer: I am not your CPA and I am not your attorney. This is education, not tax or legal advice. Talk to your own advisers before you do anything, and sit down with a CPA and a real estate attorney who have done these before you sign anything.

If you've owned rental property for 10 or 15 years, you're probably sitting on two things: a pile of equity and a tax bill with your name on it. Sell today, and between federal capital gains, depreciation recapture, and state taxes, a big chunk of your profit goes to the government. For a lot of longtime owners, it's a quarter or more.

Most investors know exactly one way around that: the 1031 exchange. Sell, buy another building, keep deferring. But a 1031 just buys you another building. That's more roofs, more turnovers, more decisions. If the whole point was to be done, you're not actually done. I'm Matthew Whitaker, founder of Evernest. We manage thousands of homes for investors in more than 50 markets, and I talk with owners about this exact exit question all the time. There's a lesser-known tool that solves it.

The short version

The short version: A 721 exchange, often called an UPREIT (umbrella partnership real estate investment trust), lets you contribute your property to a REIT's operating partnership in exchange for partnership units. Under Section 721 of the tax code, that generally isn't treated as a sale, so the tax is deferred, not forgiven. You keep collecting income and never take a maintenance call again. But it's a one-way door, so it's built for owners who are done building, not those still trading up.

What an UPREIT is, and why a 721 isn't a sale

UPREIT stands for umbrella partnership real estate investment trust, and the name tells you how it's built. There are two layers. On top is the REIT, the company people buy shares in. Underneath it is the operating partnership, usually just called the OP. The OP is what actually owns the buildings.

Here's the key: you don't buy shares in the REIT. You contribute your property to the operating partnership, and in exchange you become a partner in it. That matters because of Section 721 of the tax code. Under 721, contributing property to a partnership in exchange for an interest in that partnership generally isn't treated as a sale. If there's no sale, there's no gain to report. Not yet, anyway. The tax is deferred, not forgiven.

This structure has been around since the early 1990s. It was created so property owners could roll their real estate into a REIT without triggering a huge tax bill, and today many of the largest REITs in the country are set up this way.

How a 721 differs from a 1031

The exchange. A 1031 is real estate for real estate. A 721 is real estate for partnership units.
The rules. They're different sections of the tax code with different rules, and very different ways out.
The clock. A 1031 gives you 45 days to identify a replacement property and 180 days to close. A 721 doesn't have those clocks. The deal takes the time it takes.

How a 721 exchange works, step by step

Underwriting. The REIT looks at your property the way any buyer would: an appraisal, inspections, title, and a review of the leases. You and the REIT agree on what the property is worth.
Your contribution. You deed the property to the operating partnership under a contribution agreement. If you have a mortgage, the OP will typically take it over or pay it off as part of the deal.
You receive OP units. Those units are generally valued the same as REIT shares. If your equity in the property is $2 million, you'd receive roughly $2 million worth of OP units, and your original tax basis, the low basis you've built up over years of depreciation, carries over into those units.
Nothing hits your tax return. Under 721, you didn't sell anything. No capital gain, no depreciation recapture, at least not yet.
The lockup. Most deals won't let you convert your units right away. A holding period of around a year is common, and some are longer. Read that part of the agreement carefully before you sign.
You get paid. OP units typically earn the same distribution per unit that the REIT pays per share. Your rent checks turn into distribution checks, and you're not managing anything.
The exit. After the lockup, you can redeem your units for REIT shares or cash. That redemption is the taxable event, but you decide when it happens and how much. You could convert 10% this year and 10% next year, and spread the gain out over time.
The long game. If you hold your units until you pass away, under current law your heirs generally get a stepped-up basis, and that deferred gain can effectively go away. Your kids inherit units, not buildings. Units are easy to split. Buildings aren't, and nobody has to fight over who gets the house on Elm Street.

Two catches: debt above basis, and smaller properties

The debt trap. If you owe more on the property than your tax basis, the contribution itself can trigger a taxable gain. That's common with owners who have refinanced over the years. There are ways to negotiate around it, including what's called a tax protection agreement, but this is exactly where your CPA earns their fee. Please don't do this without one.

The smaller-owner path. Most REITs aren't going to take a single $300,000 house directly. The more common path is a two-step. First, you do a 1031 exchange into a DST, which is a fractional interest in a larger institutional property. Then, down the road, the DST sponsor may roll that property into a REIT through a 721 exchange. That's a whole topic on its own, and I'll cover it in a future video.

Who a 721 exchange is built for

Long-term owners with big embedded gains. If you've held for years and taken a lot of depreciation, your tax bill on a straight sale could be really painful. That's who this was built for.
Owners who are done operating. You just want the income, not the job. After a 721, you own a piece of a large portfolio and someone else runs it.
People thinking about their estate. Units divide cleanly between heirs. Combine that with a step-up at death, and this becomes as much an estate planning tool as a tax tool.

There are two more benefits worth mentioning. One is no deadline pressure, as covered above. The other is diversification: you trade one address in one zip code for a portfolio that spans many properties and often many markets. One bad roof or one small market can't sink you anymore.

Who should stay away

I want to be as clear about this as I was about the benefits.

You're still in growth mode. It's a one-way door. With a 1031, you can keep trading building to building as long as you want, but once you're holding OP units, you generally can't 1031 back out. Your way out is converting the units, and converting is a taxable event. This is for the end of the journey, not the middle.
You'll need the cash soon. Every dollar you pull out brings its share of deferred tax with it. If you need a big chunk of this money in the next few years, it's the wrong tool.
Your gain is small. If you bought recently or the property hasn't appreciated much, there's not much tax to defer. Just sell and keep it simple.
You're heavily leveraged. If your debt is higher than your basis, the contribution itself can be partly taxable, and overleveraged owners often can't use this cleanly.
Giving up control bothers you. The value of your units tracks the share price, distributions can be cut, and you have no say in how the properties are run. If that makes you uneasy, trust that instinct.
Your property might not fit. REITs buy what fits in their portfolio, usually larger institutional-quality properties or packages of them. A single older house usually gets in through the DST two-step, if at all.
The complexity and cost aren't worth it at your size. Contribution agreements, tax protection agreements, and K-1s at tax time instead of a simple Schedule E mean paying professionals. At the right size that's worth it. At the wrong size, it isn't.

A simple way to decide

If you're still building your portfolio, look at the 1031 and keep trading up. If you're done building, you want income and diversification, and you've got a big gain baked in, a 721 exchange belongs on your short list. If you need the cash, sell, pay the tax, and move on. Don't let the tax tail wag the dog. Sometimes a clean break is worth it. And if you're not sure, that's what the CPA conversation is for. It's a cheap conversation compared to getting this wrong.

Quick recap

You contribute your property, get OP units, and defer the tax. You collect income and convert on your own schedule, or never.
A 721 is real estate for partnership units, while a 1031 is real estate for real estate.
Watch for the lockup and the debt trap, and don't do this without a CPA.
It's a one-way door, built for owners who are done building.
Smaller owners usually reach a REIT through a 1031 into a DST first.

Frequently asked questions

What is a 721 exchange?A 721 exchange lets you contribute your property to a REIT's operating partnership in exchange for partnership units. Under Section 721 of the tax code, that generally isn't treated as a sale, so no gain is reported at the time. The tax is deferred, not forgiven.

What is an UPREIT?UPREIT stands for umbrella partnership real estate investment trust. It has two layers: the REIT on top, which people buy shares in, and an operating partnership underneath that actually owns the buildings. In a 721, you contribute your property to the operating partnership and become a partner in it.

What's the difference between a 721 exchange and a 1031 exchange?A 1031 is real estate for real estate, so you end up owning another building. A 721 is real estate for partnership units, so you end up with income and no property to manage. They fall under different sections of the tax code, with different rules and different ways out.

When do you pay tax after a 721 exchange?When you redeem your units for REIT shares or cash. That redemption is the taxable event, but you decide when it happens and how much, so you could convert 10% one year and 10% the next. If you hold the units until you pass away, your heirs generally get a stepped-up basis under current law.

Can a single rental house go into a REIT through a 721 exchange?Usually not directly. Most REITs won't take a single $300,000 house. The more common path is a 1031 exchange into a DST, a fractional interest in a larger institutional property, which the sponsor may later roll into a REIT through a 721.

Who should not do a 721 exchange?Owners still in growth mode, those who need cash soon, those with a small gain, and those whose debt exceeds their tax basis. Also anyone uncomfortable giving up control, since distributions can be cut and you have no say in how the properties are run. It's a one-way door.

How long is the lockup on OP units?A holding period of around a year is common, and some are longer. Terms vary by deal, so read the lockup section of the agreement carefully before you sign.

Where to go from here

If you want to know what your property is actually doing for you right now, our team will run a free rental analysis on it: what it should rent for and what it really costs to run. That way, whether you keep it, sell it, or roll it into something like an UPREIT, you're making the call with real numbers.

Get a free rental analysis on your property

If you're tired of managing your homes yourself but aren't ready for something like an UPREIT, we'd love to talk with you about managing your portfolio.

Talk to Evernest about managing your portfolio

No pressure, no obligation.

‍