Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis

Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis

Looking for the best property management companies in Indianapolis? As a property owner in Indianapolis, navigating the vast landscape of property management companies can feel overwhelming. From tenant screening and placement to rent collection and maintenance, entrusting your investment requires careful consideration. To alleviate the stress of this search, we've done the footwork and compiled a curated list of Indianapolis's very best property management companies. Our evaluation considers crucial factors like pricing transparency, areas of expertise, and verified Google ratings, ensuring a streamlined search for excellence. However, we understand that one size doesn't fit all. Certain situations might not necessitate a property manager. To gain valuable insights and determine if this service aligns with your specific needs, watch this video before making a decision.


Evernest was established in 2008 at the beginning of the housing crisis. Our founder, Matthew Whitaker, was left with 30 investment properties that he intended to sell but was unable to do so when the residential housing market crashed. So he searched for a property manager who shared his management philosophies and ideals. Later on in the year, Matthew launched Evernest and we officially opened for business. In the last 15 years, Evernest has grown from a team of 3 to a nationwide company with over 400 team members. Evernest is based in Birmingham and operates in dozens of real estate markets across the US. With Evernest you’ll receive in-house maintenance, no fees for cancellation, and a waived lease fee if a resident leaves within the first year. Evernest guarantees a qualified renter for your unit within 21 days, or your first two months of management are free. A 24-hour hotline is available to residents as well. CEO/Founder: Matthew Whitaker BBB rating: A+ Google rating: 4.5 / 5 (9,669 reviews) Years in business: 15 Number of people: 400+ Rentals managed: 15,000+ Number of markets: 33 Specialties: Single-family residential, condos, small multifamily (up to 49 units), rental property investing Property management fee: 8%-10% Leasing fee: 50% of one month's rent ($500 minimum) Renewal leasing fee: $250 Other services: brokerage, in-house maintenance, in-house underwriting, leasing Learn more here

Keyrenter Indianapolis North Property Management

Keyrenter is a nationwide property management company offering management services for residential, commercial, and association properties. Keyrenter Indianapolis North has a team of local experts with extensive knowledge of the local rental market, allowing them to effectively navigate tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and financial reporting. Keyrenter prides itself on being at the forefront of technology and industry best practices, making it a leader in the property management space. To get started, visit their website or contact them via email to understand the needs of your property and how Keyrenter can help. CEO/Founder: Michael Simmons BBB rating: A (not accredited) Google rating: 5 / 5 (34 reviews) Years in business: 2 Number of markets: 18 Specialties: Single-family residential, multifamily residential, commercial properties, associations Property management fee: percentage-based Leasing fee: must contact for pricing Renewal leasing fee: must contact for pricing Learn more here

CRM Properties

CRM Properties is a full-service property management and real estate company serving Indianapolis, Kokomo, and Muncie areas in Central Indiana. They have a large, regionally-local team with many years of experience between them, enabling efficient and high-quality service for real estate investors at any stage. CRM Properties’ management services are flexible, so property owners can contract their team for a-la-carte services or bring them on to manage everything end-to-end. They even offer a three-month trial period so owners can try their management services before committing to a long-term partnership. CEO/Founder: Chris Mullinax BBB rating: A+ (not accredited) Google rating: 5 / 5 (32 reviews) Years in business: 12 Number of people: 34 Rentals managed: NA Number of markets: 12 Specialties: single-family residential, multifamily residential Property management fee: percentage-based and capped Leasing fee: percentage-based and capped Renewal leasing fee: flat fee Other services: lease-only services, renovations, real estate brokerage Learn more here

Intrigue Property Management

Intrigue Property Management offers residential, commercial, and HOA management services to the Greater Indianapolis and Central Indiana markets in addition to San Antonio and Austin, Texas. Their full suite of leasing and management services can be adapted to serve property owners and real estate investors with portfolios diverse in size and complexity. CEO/Founder: Ryan Rominger BBB rating: NA Google rating: 4.8 / 5 (179 reviews) Years in business: 5 Number of people: 6 Rentals managed: NA Number of markets: 20+ Specialties: single-family residential, multifamily residential, commercial properties, HOA Property management fee: percentage-based Leasing fee: NA Renewal leasing fee: NA Other services: lease-only, eviction proceedings support, renovations Learn more here


IndyFlippers is a full-service property management company serving Indianapolis and its surrounding suburbs. Their team manages everything from marketing and tenant placement to rent collection, maintenance, and regular financial reporting. In addition to all of the critical management services, IndyFlippers offers rehab for rental properties. Alongside your property inspector, their rehab team will conduct and manage the updates your property needs to be ready to rent. CEO/Founder: Jason Warner BBB rating: A+ (accredited) Google rating: 4.8 / 5 (25 reviews) Years in business: 17 Number of people: 3 Rentals managed: NA Number of markets: 15+ Specialties: single-family residential Property management fee: percentage-based Leasing fee: flat fee Renewal leasing fee: percentage-based Other services: rental property rehab services Learn more here

Final Thoughts: Best Property Management Companies in Indianapolis

There are several things to take into account while looking for the best property management company in Indianapolis. In the end, it comes down to your circumstances and the goals you have for your property. The ideal property manager will match your personal preferences as an owner, be within your budget, and cover you where you need them most. That’s why having options is important when making the right decisions for your real estate requirements. If you’re considering Evernest as your property management company, we’d love to answer your questions!

Ready to Learn More?

Join the Evernest Educational Community! We know firsthand how hard it is to find quality resources. Oftentimes, all the information you need is scattered across the web and you’re left scrambling to find your footing. That’s why we set out to create a space where investors can get everything they need to be successful in real estate, all on one platform. We’ve put together investor tools (calculators, tutorials, and more), a listing channel where you can both buy and sell properties, a space to network with other investors and pros in the community, and more. It’s completely free to join, no strings attached. Plus, there’s something for everyone, whether you’re brand new or a seasoned pro. So what are you waiting for? Join our community today and start connecting with like-minded real estate investors who share your passions and goals. We can’t wait to welcome you into the fold!